Skip to content
PromotEdge

Home World of Marketing The Agency Conversation That Actually

Insights

The Agency Conversation That Actually Matters (And Why Most Agencies Avoid It)

By , Senior Account Manager, client servicing with Bishal NaskarPublished 7 May 2026Updated 16 Oct 20267 min read

Since 201565+ in-house team1 office in Kolkata · 5 team bases
A marketer in a red bow tie holding a sheet with three questions while listening to an owner in a Delhi agency meeting nook.
The short answer

In short

The agency conversation that matters is about accountability and results. PromotEdge agrees what will be measured, such as enquiries and sales, before the work starts, and reports against it. Creativity and credentials come second. Many agencies avoid this conversation because specifics expose gaps in their work. Ask the right questions upfront and you can separate agencies that deliver from ones that only pitch well.

Need this done for your business? A strategist can call you back in one working day.

Ask for a call back

The pitch deck was perfect and the results were invisible

A D2C (direct-to-consumer) beauty brand from Mumbai hired an agency in late 2023. The agency had big names on its client list and a sleek office in BKC. The pitch was immaculate, with market analysis, competitor positioning, channel strategy and an 18-month roadmap. The monthly fees were high.

After three months, the founder called me (off the record).

“The pitch was better than the work. We don’t know what we’re actually paying for. We’re not seeing results. And every time we ask for clarity, they send a deck instead of answering the question.”

She had hired the wrong agency because she had asked the wrong questions during selection.

This article is about the right questions to ask, the ones that show whether an agency will deliver for your business.

Agency Selection Criteria Comparison

What an agency does, and what it doesn’t

Here’s the confusion most businesses have: they think an agency brings ideas.

In fact, an agency executes your strategy, and hopefully executes it well. The strategy itself should come from you.

If you walk into an agency saying “we want to grow but don’t know how,” a good agency will dig. They’ll ask about your business, your customers, your margins, your competitive situation. Then they’ll recommend a strategy.

A bad agency will try to convince you that they know what you need. They’ll talk about “digital transformation” and “integrated omnichannel campaigns” and you’ll get confused and just say yes.

An agency is a tool, and an expensive one. The strategy is yours and they execute it.

Keep this in mind when you compare agencies.

The questions that matter

“What’s your process?” is a useless question, because every agency says its process is “strategic, data-driven and creative.”

Ask these instead:

Agency Evaluation Checklist And Red Flags

1. Walk me through a project you did. Specifically

Don’t let them slide into generalities. Pick one project. Ask: “What was the goal? What did you do in month one? What didn’t work? How did you fix it? What was the actual ROI?”

If they can’t give specific numbers, that’s a red flag.

If the project looks like a deck, with a beautiful pitch, unclear execution and vague results, that’s a red flag.

2. How do you measure success for our specific business?

They shouldn’t have a canned answer. They should ask you first: “What does success look like for you? More leads? More revenue? Better brand awareness? A different mix of customers?”

Then they should tie their work to that. “We’ll track X because that indicates progress toward your Y goal.”

If they jump straight to “we track CTR, ROAS (return on ad spend), brand lift, engagement” without understanding what matters for your business, that process won’t work for you.

3. How will we stay aligned, and how often will we talk?

Once a month? Once a week? Who talks to whom?

Good agencies we know do weekly syncs: 30 minutes, no nonsense, “what happened, what’s broken, what’s next.”

Agencies that talk to clients only once a month may be avoiding scrutiny.

4. What happens if results aren’t meeting goals?

Listen carefully to this answer.

Good agencies will say: “We pivot. We dig into the data. We find what’s broken and fix it. We might need to adjust the strategy, or we might just improve execution.”

Bad agencies will say: “Well, that usually means the market conditions, or the product wasn’t ready, or…” That is a lot of external blame.

If results are bad and the agency immediately blames everything except itself, that is not a partnership.

5. How many other clients are in my industry/size/budget range?

Some diversity is healthy, because they learn across industries. But if they have 50 other e-commerce clients and you’re a B2B manufacturer, they don’t really understand your specific challenges.

If they have no one in your space, they’ll be learning on your dime.

Red flags to watch for

Agency Red Flags Warning Guide
  • “We can guarantee 10x ROI in six months.” No agency can promise that responsibly. Walk away.
  • “We only charge a percentage of media spend, no fixed fee.” This gives the agency a reason to push you to spend more, whatever the ROI. A mix is better: a fixed base fee plus a performance bonus if results beat targets.
  • “We manage everything, don’t worry about it.” You should worry, and you should understand what’s happening. If an agency wants you completely hands-off, it may be hiding poor execution behind jargon.
  • “Our case studies are all with MNCs and Fortune 500 companies.” That’s fine, but can they handle your size? An agency built for Rs 2 crore campaigns might be clumsy with Rs 20 lakh campaigns. Ask if they work with companies your size.
  • “We specialise in [one thing only]: SEO” (search engine optimisation) or “paid ads” or “social media.” Specialists are great if that is your only need, but most Indian businesses need several channels working together. If your agency can only do one thing, you may end up stitching together three agencies and paying more for poor integration.
  • “We’re an award-winning agency.” Awards reward creativity, and results matter more. Ask about their average client ROI instead of their Cannes Lions count.
  • They can’t name clients. Every agency wants to protect client confidentiality, but they should have at least 3-4 clients they can name publicly. If they have none, something is off.

Integrated vs. specialist agencies, and why the answer isn’t obvious

Your situation: you need SEO, Google Ads, and brand strategy.

Option 1: hire three specialists, which means an SEO agency, a performance marketing agency and a branding agency.

Option 2: hire one integrated agency that does all three.

Specialists go very deep. An SEO-only agency might be very strong at technical SEO and link building, but it may not know how your Google Ads strategy affects your keyword choices, or how brand positioning influences the keywords worth targeting.

Integrated agencies see the connections. Brand strategy informs SEO keywords and ad copy, and performance marketing data informs content strategy. It works as one system.

The trade-off is that an integrated agency might not go as deep on SEO as a pure SEO specialist. The coordination and efficiency gains usually outweigh that.

For most mid-sized Indian businesses, an integrated agency is the better choice. You’re probably not big enough to manage three agencies, and you need someone who sees how everything connects.

Integrated Vs Specialist Agency Guide

The cost conversation, and why a fixed fee is probably wrong

Agencies charge three ways. The figures below are made-up examples, not our rates and not a market average:

Percentage of media spend: “15% of what you spend on ads.” Incentivises the agency to get you to spend more, which is a poor fit for you.

Fixed monthly fee: “Rs 2 lakhs a month.” Easy to budget. But then what happens if you add a new product line that requires 2x the work? The agency either does it for the same fee (bad for them, they’ll deprioritise you) or asks for more (awkward conversation).

Mixed (fixed base plus performance bonus): “Rs 1.5 lakhs base + 10% of revenue lift above target.” This lines up incentives: the agency makes more if you make more.

Or: retainer + project basis. “Rs 50,000/month for ongoing management, plus Rs 30,000 per special project like website redesign.”

Good agencies often use mixed models. The base lets them invest in you, and the bonus gives them a reason to deliver results.

If an agency quotes you a flat monthly fee without asking about your goals or budget, they are guessing instead of pricing on value. That is risky for both of you.

Onboarding: when you find out what you bought

The first month with an agency shows you what you bought.

Good agencies spend week one understanding your business before doing any work. They will audit your current situation, map how customers find and buy from you, and identify opportunities.

By week two, they’ll present findings. “Here’s what we found. Here’s what we recommend. Here’s the 90-day plan.”

Bad agencies spend week one doing work they planned in the pitch. They haven’t learned anything new about you, but they look productive.

Bad onboarding shows that the agency didn’t understand your business during the pitch. You’re two weeks in and they’re asking questions you answered before you hired them.

If that happens, escalate immediately. Something’s not aligned.

When to fire an agency (and do it fast)

Many agencies ask for a contract of 3-6 months minimum, but you don’t have to stay if things are clearly broken.

Trigger points to exit:

They can’t explain what they’re doing and why. Ever ask “why did you do that?” and get back a non-answer? That’s a problem.

Results are flat after 3 months and they don’t have a clear pivot. Some flatness is normal, but if they’re not investigating and adjusting, they’re just running the original plan and hoping it works. That is not a partnership.

Communication drops off. They go from weekly calls to monthly emails. That usually means they’ve deprioritised you internally.

You realise the strategy doesn’t actually fit your business. They promised “growth” but didn’t define what growth means for you. Now three months in, you’re measuring different metrics than they are.

If any of these happen, address it directly and give them a chance to fix it. If they don’t, move on. Three months of wrong work is worse than no work.

Need a conversation with an agency that explains itself?

We spend the first month understanding your business before we execute anything. You get a plan, not a pitch deck pretending to be strategy.

Let’s have that conversation

FAQs

Common questions

Short answers. For anything else, call or WhatsApp us.

  • Ask them to walk you through one specific project, with the goal, what did not work and the actual ROI. If they cannot give numbers, that is a red flag. Ask how they will measure success for your business, how often you will talk, and what they do when results miss the goals.

  • Be careful if an agency guarantees 10x ROI in six months, or says it will manage everything so you need not worry. Also watch for case studies only with giant companies, a claim of being award-winning without results, and no clients they can name publicly. A fee based only on a percentage of ad spend is another warning.

  • There are three ways. A percentage of media spend pushes the agency to make you spend more. A fixed monthly fee is easy to budget but awkward when work grows. A mixed model, a fixed base plus a performance bonus, lines up incentives, so the agency earns more when you do.

  • Specialists go very deep, but an integrated agency sees how brand strategy, SEO keywords, ad copy and content connect. The trade-off is that it may not go as deep on one area. For most mid-sized Indian businesses, an integrated agency is the better choice, because managing three agencies is hard.

  • Consider leaving if the agency cannot explain what it is doing and why, or if results stay flat after three months with no clear pivot. Other signs are communication dropping from weekly calls to monthly emails, or a strategy that does not fit your business. First address it directly and give them a chance to fix it.

What people say

What clients say about PromotEdge

Brands we have worked with

  • Sai Angan
  • Rupa Peekaboo
  • Tea Junction
  • Zandu Vigorex
  • Fox & Mandal
  • Veedol
  • Tata Efee
  • Avadh Sugar & Energy
  • Taj Cement
  • Weichai
  • Rerasathi
  • Honest AI
  • Walton
  • Supertron
  • Balrampur Foundation
  • Fine Organics
  • Kopran
  • Bengal Aerotropolis Projects Limited
  • FIVB
  • Hanumanta Foods
  • Linc
  • Nitya Gold & Diamonds
  • Novozymes
  • PSPL
Fine Organics
“PromotEdge and their team did an excellent job with our website. They engaged with every team member, understanding their needs with great patience before collating them into a user requirement and a design spec. The result was both aesthetically pleasing and usable. PromotEdge continues to support us and our ever-growing and very demanding wish list. We hope to grow this relationship beyond website design and into content development. I am confident that PromotEdge's team will continue to guide us in delivering product content to our global customers, making the website an important tool for product awareness and lead generation.”
Bimal ShahBimal ShahExecutive Director at Fine Organic Industries LimitedManufacturing
Rishta Foods
“PromotEdge is one of the most hard working creative agency that LISTENS ! Do I need to say anything more ?!!!!Saurav is one of the most open person I have come across who is ready to speak abt the elephant in the room , that no body wants to talk about !”
Harsh GuptaHarsh GuptaManaging Director at Rishta FoodsFMCG
iLead
“I am delighted with the successful launch of our new website, thanks to the exceptional support from PromotEdge. I extend my gratitude to Benjamin and the team for their dedication and hard work, which has resulted in a new, fresh-looking site that perfectly meets our expectations.”
Mom MitraMom MitraMarketing Head at IleadEducation
ABP Education
“Working with PromotEdge has been an enriching experience for ABP at many different levels. Your understanding of the digital space, customized brand solutions and prompt servicing have helped us achieve our brand goals with so much ease.I would like to especially thank the creative development team, the digital strategy team and above all the servicing team with whom I have worked in close association with, for their all-round support. I wish you all the best in your upcoming projects and I look forward to collaborating with you in future as well.”
Satabdi SahuSatabdi SahuLead - Brand and Content at ABP EducationEducation
Brahmaputra Volleyball League
“I really want to thank Sayantan and his team from PromotEdge because what I find good in them is that, the team.When the team is wonderful, the outcome will definitely be wonderful. I have seen the first cut of the reel which they shot the first day, and they gave us on the morning of the second day.The entire first day they worked so hard and over the night they have edited and on the morning they shared it with us.This is just fabulous and the commitment they have shown. The FIVB team has said that they are very happy with team PromotEdge.And when I showed this clip to my friends, those who are from this industry, they (also said that they) have done a fabulous work.So happy and compliments to the team -- Sayantan and PromotEdge team.Thank you.”
Abhijit BhattacharyaAbhijit BhattacharyaFormer Captain Indian VolleyBall Team; and Founder of Brahmaputra Volleyball LeagueSports
FIVB
“Hi, my name is Hitesh Malhotra. I'm working in FIVB. We are working with PromoteEdge (with Team Sayantan).I would like to give you a brief detail. So when we started this project, we had a good discussion with them. And personally, I feel PromotEdge is kind of a one stop solution for us. So basically, they provided us the whole storyboarding regarding the digital assets and how we can use those with our ambassadors programme.They helped us a lot to structurize the whole concept from our side. So in fact, there were a lot of great ideas they provided, guiding us...what we should do and what we should not do in this regard.And the best part was that they were very clear from there, from the whole blueprint. So they understood our request from the proposal and then accordingly they executed it.”
Hitesh MalhotraHitesh MalhotraSports Development at Fédération Internationale de Volleyball - FIVBSports
A Buyer's Choice Home Inspections and MACJ logo
“I've known PromotEdge for quite a few years. PromotEdge is passionate, knowledgeable, and destined for success. What stands out is their positivity, energy, passion, and innovative thinking. They bring a warm presence to their work. Best wishes to PromotEdge.”
Mahendra SurekaMahendra SurekaFounder & CEO at India MACJ - A Buyers Choice Home InspectionsReal estate
Birdman Chemeng Pvt Ltd.
“PromotEdge has been a unique creative group amongst unique creativity world. Approaching, analysing, understanding the deliverables with ethos and transferring the same into a spellbound creative identity, just cut out for clients’ requirement are signature values of the team. A huge ROI, thy name is PromotEdge.”
Rajat ChatterjeeRajat ChatterjeeHead Business Development at Birdman Chemeng Pvt Ltd.Manufacturing
Magik Lighting
“We are thoroughly impressed with the extensive knowledge and professionalism demonstrated by PromotEdge. Their adept management of our digital and creative requirements has significantly contributed to our satisfaction with their digital marketing services and expertise.”
Rahul MishraRahul MishraAssistant Manager Digital Marketing & Ecommerce at Magik LightingElectricals
Shyam Metalics Group
“We have been working with PromotEdge for almost a year. We have engaged them to manage our Digital marketing campaigns and are impressed with the outcome. Within weeks, we had noticed an increase in performance and they continuously worked on adapting to a new strategy if required to get the maximum mileage for us based on our requirements. A big thank you to their team, and I would highly recommend them to anyone who is considering growing on their Digital Space.”
Shubham GadodiaShubham GadodiaDeputy Brand Manager at Shyam Metalics GroupSteel and metals
Unimark Group
“As a progressive and emerging digital marketing company, PromotEdge is doing something right to enhance the experience of companies associated with them.The format they have created is great, there is a smooth flow of communication, great brainstorming sessions and additionally super ideations and executions.Pritha, the account manager, has always been supportive. Whether day or night, weekday or weekend, she came through and solved the problems.…”
Anish Basu MallikAnish Basu MallikMarketing Executive at Unimark GroupReal estate
Prime Volleyball League
“I would just like to congratulate, PromotEdge Led by Sayantan and his Team who have done an absolutely fantastic job of branding for the Kolkata Thunderbolts, the Branding, the social media campaign was bang on, and I think it help not just the Kolkata Thunderbolts but its really helped me because in the East there was at least one Team that looking very well promoted and branded. Thanks guyz, well done.”
Joy BhattacharjyaJoy BhattacharjyaCEO at Prime Volleyball LeagueSports
“In the city of Kolkata , there are very few full service advertising agencies which are compact, agile, quick and yet have the vision and creative /executional abilities of large reputed agencies. My experience with PromotEdge has been extremely satisfying and they have done world class job for Brand Building exercise of LION INDIA.In my professional life spanning over 4 decades I have always worked with leading agencies like Lintas, Grey, etc so my benchmarking was rather high. I am delighted to say that i did find the agency measuring up nicely on every parameter of our expectations. The team […] comes majorly from experienced staff who have had experience in large agencies. Added to this is the” young oozing with unique new.”
Hardeep SinghHardeep SinghMarketing Consultant
TATA Metaliks
“PromotEdge has been working with our organization for social media management and other creative activities. They are responsive, supportive and hard working. We look forward to a long and positive relationship with them.”
Medha SharmaMedha SharmaStrategic Head at TATA MetaliksSteel and metals
Nitya Gold & Diamonds
“I commend PromotEdge as a content and advertising partner. I applaud their top-notch team, swift problem-solving, and outstanding digital media work for my brand. I express my happiness and eagerness for a long-term partnership.”
Priyanka GuptaPriyanka GuptaDirector at Nitya Gold & DiamondsJewellery retail
Utkarsh India
“An aligned partner is always a welcoming step. Someone who can think deep through lines, understand the matrix of product management. Fortunate enough, PromotEdge has been a partner in progress for me. Their uniqueness lies in their hands down knowledge of delivering the strategy and communication needed for the hour. A practical approach to ensuring return of investment has been the day one mantra. An advisory to an executionist, the systematic approach by team PromotEdge has been the impeccable.”
Bobby SrinivasBobby SrinivasChief Manager Marketing & Brand Marketing at Utkarsh IndiaSteel and metals
PRAN-RFL Group logo
“PRAN & PromotEdge have been working together for last 1.5 years. Throughout, the work experience is good and satisfactory.As a client, we found PromotEdge very professional and dedicated towards any project assigned to them.Most importantly, They have a bunch of energetic young people who always think from clients’ point of view and come up with the solution which is appropriate for them.I would personally refer PromotEdge to those who want creative and contemporary work.We wish PromotEdge a successful journey ahead.”
Sharif Rezwan KabirSharif Rezwan KabirBrand Manager at PRAN RFL GroupFMCG
“It’s a great way to be back at PromotEdge. I had a great time working them in Kolkata Tunderbolts doing the Volley Biswas character and they all are like good friends like family Saurav Bhaiya, […], and as I speak, I see Sayantan da walking in. HA HA! But it’s been a great experience I am glad to again meeting them and being here at the PromotEdge. Make Calcutta relevant again.”
Priyam GhosePriyam GhoseContent Creator
“I had a great time in Kolkata, I met entire PromotEdge team and they are amazing. Design language that they follow is crazy, the copywriting is crazy. I think they are one of the best digital marketing agencies, not just in Kolkata, entire eastern region and I think brand should not leave the chance to interact with these guys, make stories together.So, if I had something here, I would have definitely collaborated with them and worked. Now is the time, I mean it’s not even a question whether digital is important or not you don’t have an option today. Go digital work with PromotEdge and create your brand stories. Thank You.”
Manish PandeyManish PandeyConsultant & Coach to Content Creator
“The PromotEdge Agency stay with us all these 3 days, since when we arrived..more, more than 3 days. Since in the airport, they stayed together with us (FIVB team).Sayantan and his team is providing you to see this video.I just (want to say) _Shukriya_. Thank you so much for your team, because we are here in front of the camera but all the team is behind. The entire team together did this great job so that you can see how much volleyball is a lovely sport.”
GibaGibaBrazilian Former Volleyball PlayerSports
Read all 20 testimonials
Talk to us

Want help with this?

Leave your name and number. A strategist calls you back in one working day.

  • One page, six answers.
  • Where the growth is, what to say, which channels.
  • A starting budget, quick wins, what to measure.
WhatsApp us

Free. No obligation. You can take the plan to another agency.

We use these details only to reply to you, by call or WhatsApp. Privacy policy.

Or call us: +91 98366 39955