Creative or Just Noisy? Are you working with the right ad agency

Updated Date

Nov-29-2025
Views

2 Min Read

The advertising sector has been gradually changing over the years since we started focusing more on digital platforms. But this year has seen the biggest shift yet. For urban hubs, where trends always jump from one to another, advertising is not just a way for promotion but a way to build brand recognition. And that is why working with advertising agencies in metro cities is now more challenging. Since the market has been overloaded with AI-generated content, consumer behaviour is also slowly changing. They are fed up with the same kind of content coming in the feed again and again. In such a critical situation, if you can’t make a difference, your brand voice will get lost. What brands truly need right now is creativity and storytelling that stands out. And it goes for all businesses, including B2B, B2C, and D2C, regardless of their sizes. So, whether you are collaborating with a digital advertising agency in Mumbai or planning to do so in the future, you can’t just blindly rely on their reviews on Google or other sites. You need to do a bit more research. In this article, we will guide you on how you can choose the right agency that matches your brand’s needs perfectly, because this year isn’t exactly following the old advertising playbook:

How the Advertising Landscape Has Shifted

When we consider advertising, it is more about being professional and polished. But now, it will take the biggest hit. With AI-generated content flooding every platform, businesses are now facing a new kind of sameness, creatives that look polished but feel identical. Deloitte’s latest Digital Media Trends report sums up this perfectly. Consumers may be consuming more content than ever, but they’re engaging with far less of it. At the same time, India has fully moved into the era of “moving screens,” where people jump between mobile, OTT, social, and outdoor digital displays within seconds. This multiscreen behaviour has shortened attention spans and raised the bar for creative work. Ads must hook instantly and deliver meaning. For small-scale companies and entrepreneurs who want to build a brand, strong creative thinking isn’t optional; it’s the only way to break through clutter. And with the current market filled with advertising agencies, brands need a company that has the potential to blend creativity with data, strategy, and performance, because reach alone simply isn’t enough anymore.

What Modern Businesses Should Expect from an Advertising Agency

Businesses should expect far more from an advertising agency than polished posts and regular uploads. Here’s what you should expect :

Expect Strong Creative Thinking Without Repetition

Predictable ideas don’t work anymore. Audiences are tired of recycled formats, AI-generated templates, and look-alike campaigns. A good agency should bring original concepts, not variations of what’s already trending. They should understand human behaviour, not just platform trends. Creativity isn’t just about visuals; it’s about fresh storytelling, emotional hooks, and the ability to make people stop scrolling.

Expect Strategic Direction, Not Just Designs

You should choose an agency that guides with clarity. This includes

Understanding your industry,
Your competitors,
Your target audience, and
The messaging that moves them.

Working with one of the best advertising agencies in Mumbai gives you a sense of assurance. They explain why a creative idea matters, how it supports your goals, and where it fits in the bigger picture.

Expect Digital Maturity, the Real Work, Real Numbers

Even as a brand owner, you should have some form of digital understanding. And for the agency you are partnering with, it is a must. They should know

How Meta works,
How Google behaves,
What boosts YouTube Shorts, and
How audiences react in different funnel stages.

They must connect creative decisions to actual performance outcomes, such as leads, conversions, retention, and recall, rather than focusing on reach alone.

Expect Transparent Reporting & Communication

Brands deserve visibility. A professional agency should provide clear dashboards, simple KPIs, honest explanations, and timely reporting without hiding behind jargon. Transparent communication means telling you what’s working, what isn’t, and how they’re improving things. You shouldn’t feel lost or confused during a campaign.

How to Find an Agency That Actually Understands Your Brand

Now that you know what to expect from an advertising agency, here’s how you can find a reliable agency:

1. Know what you want from your agency

Before searching for an agency, be clear about why you need one:

Are you trying to build awareness?
Improve your conversions?
Or, refresh your brand identity?

If you want the ads to work, they need to be connected with your audience. You can’t just think of it from a sales perspective. If you know what you want, your agency will be able to provide you with better ideas.

2. Check the agency’s creative portfolio for originality, not just aesthetics

Being the nature of the work, most ad agencies will show you polished work. But is the content or thought behind it original? That's the real concern. Look for campaigns that feel fresh and a bit out-of-the-box, not predictable. See whether they have worked with multiple clients of the same industry, and how different each one is. It will give you a better idea of their creative knowledge and talent.

3. Ask how they develop creative ideas (their process reveals everything)

This is one of the biggest filters. At a professional agency like PromotEdge, we explain our creative process:

Where ideas come from,
How they brainstorm,
How they refine concepts,
How do they test what will resonate with the audience?

But if your agency cannot explain how they think, they probably don’t think strategically.

4. Consider whether their creative and performance teams work together

What’s the value of a creative if it doesn’t perform well? So, you need to know whether the strategies and creatives are actually designed based on performance. If you want, then you can arrange a call and ask how their designers, writers, strategists, and performance marketers collaborate.

5. Ask for case studies showing how creative impacted results

When choosing the best advertising agencies, look into case studies. The actual ones, where you know which brands they have worked for. The challenges they faced, exactly what approaches the agency took and how it left an impact. You’re not looking for “nice posts”, you’re looking for evidence that creative thinking led to:

Lower CPC,
Higher engagement,
Better recall,
More leads or sales.

6. Understand their production capability

Even the greatest ideas will fail if they can’t be executed well. Check whether the agency has in-house production or relies completely on freelancers. Ask about:

Video quality,
Editing capability,
Turnaround time,
Ability to produce in different formats (Reels, YouTube Shorts, ads, OOH).

7. Review their understanding of your industry

While it may stretch the timeline a bit, check how much the agency knows about your brand. A creative agency doesn't need years of experience in your sector. But they should understand your customer and what they want. No wonder, ad campaigns often fail even with a great storyline and good quality. If they don’t know your challenges, your buyer mindset, or your market landscape, their creative ideas won’t connect.

8. Check transparency, speed, and communication practices

Good communication is a huge part of a successful partnership. A reliable ad agency in Mumbai should share with you:

Clear timelines,
Honest feedback,
Transparent budgets,
Timely reports,
Fast responses.

Red Flags to Watch Out for

When you are looking for advertising agencies in Mumbai, be aware of these:

1. Recycled or AI-Generated Templates

The problem is not using AI, but how they use it. If their portfolio feels “same-same,”then it's a major red flag. Every brand is different, so the colours, fonts, and layout should also be different. But if it looks the same, it reflects low creative thinking and no brand understanding.

2. No Strategic Reasoning Behind Creative Decisions

It’s okay to want your ads to look aesthetic. But that shouldn’t be the only factor. A serious red flag is when an agency cannot explain why a creative idea works, who it is designed for, or what insight inspired it. This usually means:

They’re creating blind content,
There is no research,
No understanding of consumer psychology, and
No alignment with your business goals

3. No Proof of Performance

Like we mentioned, you need real proof. If they only talk about “reach,” “likes,” and “awareness” without proof, then you should not rely on them. Go for a digital advertising agency in Mumbai that shows clear proof of

Leads,
Conversions,
Engagement improvement,
Cost efficiency, and
ROI.

4. Slow Turnaround Time

Digital trends disappear within hours, not days. If an agency takes too long to respond, delays feedback, or needs weeks to deliver creatives, your brand will constantly miss opportunities. Speed matters because:

platforms move fast
audiences react instantly
competition is nonstop
A slow agency can stall your momentum and hurt your brand’s presence.

5. Overpromising Results

Any agency promising viral content, extremely low ad costs, or overnight brand growth is selling you a dream. Professional agencies talk about:

testing
optimising
understanding data
iterating ideas
gradual improvement

Final Thoughts

Advertising has no limit in today’s digital world. Standing in the present, what brands need to figure out when choosing an agency is how they add value to their brand. Ads are not just a marketing tool, they are also a part of their branding. So, when choosing the best advertising agency in Mumbai, be sure of your expectations and thoroughly check the agency’s potential before making a decision.

FAQs

Q.1. How do I know which is the best advertising agency for my brand?

Look for originality in their work, strong strategy, real performance results, and clear communication. The “best” agency is the one that understands your brand, not just the one with big names.

Q.2. What should I check before hiring a digital advertising agency?

Check their creative portfolio, case studies, process, team structure, and reporting system. Make sure they can explain how ideas are made and how results are measured.

Q.3. How do I differentiate between a good agency and an average one?

A good agency brings fresh ideas, backs them with insights, delivers on performance, and stays transparent. An average one focuses only on posting content.